Opinion: sharing the wealth of green energy equitable for farmers

Farmers across this pro­vince need the opportunity to di­versify their income base through the opportunities pro­vided by the Green Energy Act and the feed-in tariff program.

However, there is growing frustration in the countryside that “have” and “have-not” situ­ations are developing. The Christian Farmers Federation of Ontario is looking at ways to share the wealth of energy con­tracts that are proliferating across Ontario.

A strong potential exists for neighbours to be at odds with each other because of the way wind turbine contracts are be­ing distributed across the coun­tryside. Winner and losers are being created in the country­side because some are the “lucky ones” to land a turbine contract while others lose the economic opportunity. This situation is creating an atmos­phere of frustration, envy, and disappointment among neigh­bours.

Years ago, when oil and gas wells were being drilled across the province, a similar situation existed, with some being able to reap the wealth under the soil. In the end, this situation was resolved through the de­vel­opment of pooling and spac­ing agreements that required recognition and sharing of the wealth of this resource.

The question that comes to my mind is that when you get down to brass tacks, is the wealth of oil under the land really any different than the wealth of wind power above it? These wind turbines carry a footprint that effectively push­es back the development of other wind turbines in a given area.

If these frustrations are to be mitigated, there is the need to recognize this impact and share the wealth of wind tur­bines that are put in place by large wind companies under contract with land owners. An equitable sharing of the wealth and the risks involved is re­quired to quell some of the frustration and anger that is brewing in the countryside.

The CFFO continues to ex­amine this serious issue. The positive economic opportu­ni­ties of green energy for some land owners have to be bal­anced against the negative so­cial impacts and lost economic benefits that these projects create for others.

By sharing the wealth, neighbours should be able to look at green energy in a positive light, regardless of which side of the fence the project sits on.

Nathan Stevens is the Research and Policy Advisor for the Christian Farmers Federation of Ontario. The CFFO commentary represents the opinions of the writer and does not necessarily represent CFFO policy.