Dear Editor:
Much like his apparent role models south of the border, Pierre Poilievre maintains that his vocal opposition to what he calls “wokeism” is in support of meritocracy. Meritocracy certainly reflects values many Canadians, including myself, admire: fairness, hard work and self-reliance. However, Poilievre’s rhetoric once again oversimplifies complex societal challenges and undermines the fairness he claims to champion.
Too many Canadians are still held back by obvious barriers –income inequality, discrimination and unequal access to education – making true meritocracy elusive. Despite Poilievre’s wishful thinking, roadblocks preventing skilled and hard-working Canadians from succeeding and being compensated on an equal footing remain an uncomfortable but objective fact.
Of course, in the real world, a perfectly level playing field is not attainable, but to cite just one example, with women’s wages averaging less than 80% of men’s, Canada still has a considerable way to go. Unfortunately, Poilievre’s simplistic invoking of “meritocracy” as a solution provides a convenient excuse for maintaining the status quo. Ignoring the obstacles presented by prejudice, accessibility and historical disadvantage only perpetuates existing inequalities. Recognizing and dismantling these barriers is essential; our country simply can’t afford to squander the talent and creativity of any fellow Canadians.
Poilievre’s criticism of “wokeism” may speak to some legitimate concerns about bureaucratic overreach and divisive identity politics. However, his blanket and often scornful dismissal of equity and inclusivity initiatives as “garbage” undermines their legitimate purpose of ensuring that merit is not obscured by systemic disadvantage.
Poilievre’s infatuation with inflammatory rhetoric may energize those opposed to progressive change, but does little to address issues important to Canadians. Canadians need affordable housing, accessible health care and education, and meaningful environmental protection. Solutions to these challenges will require empowering all Canadians, not fuelling discord for partisan gain. Securing our place in this rapidly changing world requires an all-hands-on-deck approach, not polarizing slogans that too often provide cover for hate and bigotry.
Building an authentic and just meritocracy is important, but creating more opportunities for the success of qualified, dedicated and energetic Canadians is equally critical. When we embrace diverse perspectives, skills and experiences, we expand opportunities for everyone.
The pie we share can only grow when we can all contribute to it.
To Wellington-Halton Hills MP Michael Chong: your constituents surely deserve better than your leader’s divisive blustering. It would be so much better to hear your voice clearly advocating for policies that would give all Canadians a fair chance in a genuine meritocracy. That is a vision many of us would get behind.
Jonathan Schmidt,
Elora